Fifth Avenue Collection Review: Is It Legit Jewelry MLM or a Scam?

Updated on by
Fifth Avenue Collection Review

Fifth Avenue Collection is a company that specializes in selling jewelry for women through the multi-level marketing (MLM) model. In this Fifth Avenue Collection MLM review, you’ll learn if we think the company is a legitimate MLM or a scam. You’ll also discover who launched Fifth Avenue Collection and when, what products the company sells, how to join Fifth Avenue Collection and the company’s compensation plan, whether the company has faced any complaints or lawsuits what we like about Fifth Avenue Collection and what we don’t like, and alternatives to Fifth Avenue Collection.

Who launched Fifth Avenue Collection and when?

The Butler famiiy launched Fifth Avenue Collection in Toronto, Canada in 1985. The company started as a home-based business selling costume jewelry and expanded into the United States in 1999. Fifth Avenue Collection is a member of the Direct Selling Association (DSA) and the Canadian Direct Selling Association (CDSA).

The Fifth Avenue Collection was founded by husband and wife team, Barry and Lynda Butler. They were later joined by their son, David Butler.

Barry Butler had over 30 years of experience in the jewelry industry before Fifth Avenue Collection. This included working for a wholesale costume jewelry company and then starting his own home-based business selling costume jewelry. Lynda Butler was a stay-at-home mom who helped with the family business when it first started. David Butler has a background in marketing and joined Fifth Avenue Collection in 1999 to help expand the business into the United States.

The Fifth Avenue Collection was founded with the mission of providing high quality fashion jewelry at an affordable price. The company offers a wide range of jewelry styles to suit all tastes, from classic and sophisticated to trendy and fun. Fifth Avenue Collection’s goal is to help women look and feel their best by offering beautiful, well-made jewelry that is affordable and easy to wear.

The Fifth Avenue Collection gets its name from Fifth Avenue in New York City. Fifth Avenue is one of the most famous streets in the world and is known for its high-end shops and luxury brands. The Fifth Avenue Collection strives to offer the same level of style and quality as the designers and brands found on Fifth Avenue, but at a fraction of the price.

What products does Fifth Avenue Collection sell?

Fifth Avenue Collection sells a wide range of jewelry for women, including earrings, necklaces, bracelets, rings, and sets. The company’s jewelry is made from high quality materials, such as Swarovski crystals, freshwater pearls, sterling silver, and 14-karat gold. Fifth Avenue Collection’s jewelry is also lead- and nickel-free, making it hypoallergenic.

Fifth Avenue Collection products:

  • Earrings: Fifth Avenue Collection offers a wide variety of earrings, including studs, hoops, dangle earrings, and more.
  • Necklaces: Fifth Avenue Collection offers a wide variety of necklaces, including pendants, chains, and sets.
  • Bracelets: Fifth Avenue Collection offers a wide variety of bracelets, including bangles, charm bracelets, and more.
  • Rings: Fifth Avenue Collection offers a wide variety of rings, including cocktail rings, stackable rings, and more.
  • Sets: Fifth Avenue Collection offers a wide variety of sets, including earring and necklace sets, bracelet and ring sets, and more.
  • Handbags: Fifth Avenue Collection offers a wide variety of handbags, including clutches, shoulder bags, and more.
  • Scarves: Fifth Avenue Collection offers a wide variety of scarves, including pashminas, infinity scarves, and more.

How does Fifth Avenue Collection work?

Fifth Avenue Collection is a multi-level marketing (MLM) company. The company sells its products through a network of independent sales consultants, who earn commissions on their sales. Fifth Avenue Collection also offers incentives and bonuses to its sales consultants, such as trips and cars.

Sales consultants earn an income by selling Fifth Avenue Collection products and recruiting other sales consultants to join the company. Fifth Avenue Collection offers a tiered commission structure, which pays sales consultants a higher percentage on their sales as they move up in rank. Sales consultants can also earn bonuses and incentives, such as trips and cars, for meeting certain sales goals. Fifth Avenue Collection’s compensation plan also includes a retail profit component, which allows sales consultants to earn a profit on the retail price of Fifth Avenue Collection products they sell.

Fifth Avenue Collection’s commission structure has 4 levels:

  • Sales Associate: Sales Associates earn a 20% commission on their personal sales.
  • Director: Directors earn a 25% commission on their personal sales. In addition, they earn a 3% override commission on the sales of their downline.
  • Senior Director: Senior Directors earn a 30% commission on their personal sales. In addition, they earn a 5% override commission on the sales of their downline.
  • Executive Director: Executive Directors earn a 35% commission on their personal sales. In addition, they earn a 7% override commission on the sales of their downline.

In order to qualify for commissions and overrides, Fifth Avenue Collection sales consultants must maintain a minimum monthly sales volume. For Sales Associates, the minimum monthly sales volume is $250. For Directors, the minimum monthly sales volume is $500. For Senior Directors, the minimum monthly sales volume is $1,000. And for Executive Directors, the minimum monthly sales volume is $2,500.

How much does it cost to join Fifth Avenue Collection?

How much does it cost to join Fifth Avenue Collection

The Fifth Avenue Collection website does not disclose the cost of joining the company. However, Fifth Avenue Collection's compensation plan states that sales consultants must purchase a starter kit in order to start selling Fifth Avenue Collection products. Fifth Avenue Collection's starter kits range in price from $199 to $499.

Fifth Avenue Collection's starter kits include Fifth Avenue Collection jewelry, a Fifth Avenue Collection catalog, a Fifth Avenue Collection order form, and Fifth Avenue Collection business cards.

Fifth Avenue Collection does offer support to its sales consultants. The company provides sales consultants with access to Fifth Avenue Collection’s website, Fifth Avenue Collection’s jewelry, Fifth Avenue Collection’s catalog, Fifth Avenue Collection’s order form, Fifth Avenue Collection’s business cards, and Fifth Avenue Collection’s training materials. In addition, Fifth Avenue Collection offers a mentoring program for its sales consultants.

Is Fifth Avenue Collection a pyramid scheme?

Fifth Avenue Collection is not a pyramid scheme. Fifth Avenue Collection is a legitimate multi-level marketing company. Under a pyramid scheme, participants only make money by recruiting other participants into the scheme. Fifth Avenue Collection sales consultants earn an income by selling Fifth Avenue Collection products and recruiting other sales consultants to join the company. Fifth Avenue Collection’s compensation plan also includes a retail profit component, which allows sales consultants to earn a profit on the retail price of Fifth Avenue Collection products they sell.

How about complaints or lawsuits?

We could not find any complaints or lawsuits that have been filed against the company.

What we like about Fifth Avenue Collection

  • Fifth Avenue Collection offers a tiered commission structure, which pays sales consultants a higher percentage on their sales as they move up in rank.
  • Fifth Avenue Collection’s compensation plan also includes a retail profit component, which allows sales consultants to earn a profit on the retail price of Fifth Avenue Collection products they sell.
  • Fifth Avenue Collection offers support to its sales consultants in the form of access to Fifth Avenue Collection’s website, Fifth Avenue Collection’s jewelry, Fifth Avenue Collection’s catalog, Fifth Avenue Collection’s order form, Fifth Avenue Collection’s business cards, and Fifth Avenue Collection’s training materials. Fifth Avenue Collection also offers a mentoring program for its sales consultants.

What we don’t like about Fifth Avenue Collection?

  • We could not find any information on the Fifth Avenue Collection website about the cost of joining the company. Fifth Avenue Collection’s compensation plan states that sales consultants must purchase a starter kit in order to start selling Fifth Avenue Collection products. Fifth Avenue Collection’s starter kits range in price from $199 to $499.
  • Fifth Avenue Collection’s compensation plan requires sales consultants to maintain a minimum monthly sales volume. For Sales Associates, the minimum monthly sales volume is $250. For Directors, the minimum monthly sales volume is $500. For Senior Directors, the minimum monthly sales volume is $1,000. For Executive Directors, the minimum monthly sales volume is $2,500.

Alternatives to Fifth Avenue Collection

If you are interested in selling jewelry for women, there are several other companies that offer similar products and opportunities, including:

  • Stella & Dot: Stella & Dot offers a wide range of jewelry, including necklaces, earrings, bracelets, and rings. Stella & Dot’s starter kits start at $199.
  • Paparazzi Accessories: Paparazzi Accessories’ starter kits start at $99.
  • Kendra Scott: Kendra Scott offers a wide range of jewelry, including necklaces, earrings, bracelets, and rings. Kendra Scott’s starter kits start at $199.
  • 30 Minute Wait: 30 Minute Wait offers a wide range of jewelry, including necklaces, earrings, bracelets, and rings. 30 Minute Wait’s starter kits start at $299.

Our verdict on Fifth Avenue Collection

Our verdict on Fifth Avenue Collection

We recommend Fifth Avenue Collection as a legitimate multi-level marketing company that offers a tiered commission structure and a retail profit component in its compensation plan. Fifth Avenue Collection also offers support to its sales consultants in the form of access to Fifth Avenue Collection's website, Fifth Avenue Collection's jewelry, Fifth Avenue Collection's catalog, Fifth Avenue Collection's order form, Fifth Avenue Collection's business cards, and Fifth Avenue Collection's training materials. Fifth Avenue Collection also offers a mentoring program for its sales consultants. However, we could not find any information on the Fifth Avenue Collection website about the cost of joining the company. Fifth Avenue Collection's compensation plan states that sales consultants must purchase a starter kit in order to start selling Fifth Avenue Collection products. Fifth Avenue Collection's starter kits range in price from $199 to $499. Fifth Avenue Collection's compensation plan also requires sales consultants to maintain a minimum monthly sales volume. If you are interested in selling jewelry for women, there are several other companies that offer similar products and opportunities, including Stella & Dot, Paparazzi Accessories, Kendra Scott, and 30 Minute Wait.

Thoroughly research MLM companies

Before joining any multi-level marketing company, it’s crucial that you thoroughly research that company. Not all MLM companies are created equal. Some MLM companies are legitimate businesses with quality products, while others are nothing more than pyramid schemes designed to take your money.

When researching an MLM company, pay close attention to that company’s:

  • Product: Is the product something that people will actually want to buy? Is it a quality product?
  • Compensation plan: Does the compensation plan reward recruitment more than actual sales of products? Is the compensation structure sustainable?
  • History: Has the company been involved in any lawsuits? Have there been complaints filed against the company with the Better Business Bureau?

If you have any doubts about an MLM company, it’s best to steer clear of that company and look for another opportunity.

I Buy I Review is one of your best sources of information on multi-level marketing companies. Our mission is to provide accurate and unbiased reviews of MLM companies based on the following criteria:

  • Product
  • Compensation plan
  • History
  • Complaints or lawsuits

We believe that you should have all of the information you need to make an informed decision about whether or not to join an MLM company.