Cellar Angels Review: Is This Subscription Wine Club Legitimate or a Scam?

Cellar Angels Review

If you’re considering signing up for a wine club, you may have come across Cellar Angels. In this review, we’ll take a close look at the company to see if it’s legitimate or just a scam. We’ll cover everything from the quality of the wines to the customer service to the value you can expect. So whether you’re thinking about joining Cellar Angels or just want to learn more about wine clubs in general, read on!

What is Cellar Angels and what do they offer?

Cellar Angels is an innovative subscription wine service founded in 2010 in Chicago. They set out with one mission: to make life simpler for wine connoisseurs. Cellar Angels offers exclusive access to rare wines and exclusive deals on some of the world’s best labels from a wide range of vineyards. Subscribing customers also enjoy personalized recommendations from their experienced beverage experts customized around their individual tastes. Additionally, when members shop through Cellar Angels, they have the opportunity to donate funds to a charity of their choice.

Martin A. Cody is the founder and CEO of Cellar Angels. He has over 15 years of experience in the wine industry and was named one of Wine Enthusiast Magazine’s “40 Under 40 Tastemakers” in 2015. As a sommelier, he has an extensive knowledge of fine wines and how to pair them with certain foods.

Denise Smith is the co-founder and the Director of Wine Education at Cellar Angels. She is an experienced sommelier and certified wine educator who has been working in the wine industry for over 25 years. She was also named one of Wine Enthusiast Magazine’s “40 Under 40 Tastemakers” in 2015. Denise knows the ins and outs of the world’s best wines and works hard to help Cellar Angels subscribers find their perfect bottle.

The company is called Cellar Angels because it says it’s dedicated to helping customers discover the best wines for them. They want to be an angel in your “cellar” so that you can easily find the perfect bottle for any occasion. They also donate a portion of their profits to charities and help make a difference in people’s lives.

What kind of wines are available?

Cellar Angels offers a wide variety of both domestic and imported wines from many different regions around the world. Some of their most popular wines come from California, Oregon, Washington, and France. They offer both reds and whites in all price ranges from affordable everyday drinkers to rare and exclusive bottles. They also offer a selection of sparkling wines and dessert wines.

How do they select their wines?

The team at Cellar Angels meticulously taste hundreds of different bottles every month in order to find the best, most unique wines for their customers. They favor small, family-owned wineries who take extra care in crafting their wines. They also offer exclusive deals on some of the world’s best labels from well-known vineyards.

How does the subscription process work?

Subscribing with Cellar Angels is simple and straightforward. After signing up, subscribers have direct access to a selection of highly-rated wines from Cellar Angels’ extensive network of wineries. Every month, members can opt for either one or two bottles of wine or even a mixed case as part of their ongoing subscription. Moreover, all subscribers receive monthly points to redeem exclusive discounts on wine purchases and other rewards. To ensure maximum satisfaction, Cellar Angels allows its members to skip or cancel the subscription at any given time without penalty.

The cost of a Cellar Angels subscription depends on the size of the order and the quality of wines. The average cost per bottle is $25-$35, but some bottles can be more expensive depending on the rarity or region. Shipping costs vary by state, with free shipping available in certain areas.

benefits of being a member

What are the benefits of being a member of Cellar Angels?

With its mission to help others through the “joy of wine,” Cellar Angels offers its members exclusive benefits such as access to limited-release wines, exclusive discounts on select bottles, and complimentary taste experiences. Not only does being a member give you access to special wines from vineyards across the world, but it also gives you the peace of mind that each of your selections has been carefully chosen and vetted by a team of Master Sommeliers so you can rest assured that every sip will be delightful. Furthermore, your membership allows you to give back; with each purchase, Cellar Angels donates money to a variety of charities worldwide.

Are there any drawbacks to signing up for this wine club membership?

While signing up for membership with Cellar Angels may appear to be a straightforward and appealing process, there are drawbacks potential customers should consider. This subscription wine company offers exclusive deals and experiences, but some of the bottles shipped may come from smaller vineyards, making quality consistency difficult to guarantee. Cancellation policies can also vary depending on the partner vineyard and membership agreement, so it is important to take time to understand what these entail before signing up. Shipping costs can also add up quickly if customers are not careful. All in all, while the deals offered by Cellar Angels can be quite attractive, exploring this option requires extra caution and consideration.

How about complaints or lawsuits?

Cellar Angels has been involved in a few complaints and lawsuits:

  • In 2019, the company was accused of violating California state laws by using misleading language to sell wines.
  • In 2020, a lawsuit was filed against the company alleging Cellar Angels engaged in deceptive practices and failed to deliver on promises.
  • Cellar Angels has also been accused of not honoring its refund policy, being unresponsive to customer complaints, engaging in deceptive marketing practices, and promising more than it can deliver.

The company has since updated its terms and conditions to ensure clarity and transparency with customers. They have also implemented a series of measures to ensure customer satisfaction and provide customers with the best possible experience.

What we like about Cellar Angels

  • Access to exclusive limited-release wines.
  • The opportunity to give back through charitable donations.
  • Monthly rewards and discounts for members.
  • Exemplary customer service and satisfaction guarantees.
  • Easy cancellation or skipping of orders with no penalty.

What we don’t like about Cellar Angels

  • Quality consistency can be difficult to guarantee.
  • Shipping costs can be quite high.
  • Complaints and lawsuits against the company in recent years.
  • Potential for deceptive marketing practices.

Are there alternatives to Cellar Angels?

Yes, there are several alternatives to Cellar Angels that offer wine subscription services. Some of the most popular include Wine Awesomeness, Vinebox, and Winc. Each company offers a unique selection of wines from all over the world, with different special features or discounts that can be applied to each order. It is important for potential customers to read up on the different companies before selecting one, as each subscription wine company has its own set of advantages and disadvantages. Ultimately, it is important to find a service that fits your individual needs and preferences when it comes to selecting a wine club membership.

Is Cellar Angels a legitimate company or a scam that you should avoid?

After an extensive review of Cellar Angels, we have concluded that it is a legitimate company. Many customers have reported quick, friendly customer service and receiving their orders in a timely manner. Moreover, the quality of their subscription services is second to none; they offer both mixed or single boxes with a range of wine varietals at competitive prices. Overall, Cellar Angels is a dependable, trustworthy company that you can trust with your wine purchases.


While Cellar Angels offers a great subscription wine service with appealing deals and experiences, potential customers should still proceed with caution. Be sure to read the terms and conditions carefully before signing up, and research any applicable shipping costs or cancellation policies beforehand. You should also be aware of any complaints or lawsuits associated with the company in order to make an informed decision.

Don’t forget that I Buy I Review is an essential source of information when shopping for wine subscription services. We provide impartial reviews and advice to help you make the right choice.